Issue 18, Page 106
EVERY SCIENCE IN A MAJOR CULTURE HAS ITS GOLDEN age and my
treatment of Andalusian science will focus on this period. Once that
science is situated in time and space, it will help those of us living
in a different time and very pluralistic world to better appreciate its
significance. The period between the eighth and 15th centuries – or the
second and ninth centuries of the Islamic calendar – tends to evoke for
Westerners distant images of darkness, confìicts between men of religion
and men of science, intellectual barrenness, religious intolerance and
so on. The immediate reference is to medieval Europe, but it is assumed
that elsewhere in the world, the prevailing situation must have been the
same. As history tells us, however, Andalusia (as Muslimruled Spain was
known) can hardly be associated with such unfavorable images. On the
contrary, Andalusia has charmed students of its history, culture and
civilizational achievements. Many authors have lavished the region with
praise in their writings, evoking images of enlighttenment and
tolerance. Philosoph}1, science, literature and the arts flourished.
Several of its natives, such as Ibn al-’Arabi from Murcia, became among
the greatest spiritual thinkers. Andalusia was perhaps the only place in
Europe where followers of the three Abrahamic faiths – Muslims,
Christians and Jews lived together in relative peace, produced a common
culture and civilization, and maintained this culture over a long period
of time. No wonder some Westerners today are nostalgic for Andalusia.
Andalusia was rivaled in knowledge, wealth and power only by the
Muslim East, but the Spanish region itself was the Muslim West. Although
its body was in Europe, in mind and spirit, it was closer to the
Arab-Muslim world. Intelectually spiritually and culturali)1, Andalusia
was part and parcel of the vast Muslim world that extended from the
Atlantic coast of the Iberian Peninsula in the west to China in the
east.
Andalusia’s contributions to Islam had been immense, though the same can
be said of its contributions to the Latin West. Its intellectual
contributions were largely in the field of mathematics, natural science
and medicine. Arab-Muslim science in Andalusia flourished for several
centuries. Its origin and rapid growth as a scholarly effort and as a
statesupported institution could be traced to the 10th century
patronization of scholarship initiated by Abdul Rahman III (d.961),
founder of the Umayyad caliphate in Cordova. He sought to create a new
learning culture in Andalusia on the basis of the cultural and
scientific achievements of Baghdad. His son, Al-Hakam II (d.976),
energetically continued this court tradition of learning and
scholarship.
The golden age of Andalusian science ought to be identified with the 1
1 th and 1 2th centuries, when all the big names lived. The period was
the most productive in terms of scientific creativity and literary
output, but the brilliance was not unique to Andalusia. Although the
region might have been the most advanced center of scientific activities
in Europe, on the larger international stage, it shared the limelight
with other places such as the Middle East and Central Asia. It was not
just the golden age of Andalusian science, but also the golden age of
Islamic science as a whole. This fact provides evidence that Andalusian
science was part of a larger scientific enterprise within the cultural
unity fostered by Islam. To the Muslim world, Andalusia was its
westernmost wing, which, together with the rest of the Maghreb,
constituted a single cultural unit.
It was remarkable at that time to see a lot of exchange of scientific
information between Andalusia and the rest of the Muslim world. Quite a
number of men of science from Andalusia were known to have traveled to
the Muslim East and just as many from the East traveled to Andalusia for
various reasons. Historical records point to many scholars making
frequent long distance travels within the Muslim world and beyond. Such
travels were a significant factor in the internationalization and
globalization of Islamic science.
ANDALUSIAN SCIENTISTS: NAMESTO REMEMBER
I use the word “scientist” to include mathematicians, natural
scientists, medical doctors and geographers. The word “scientist” is of
course a modern invention. Scientists as specialists in the modern sense
were practically nonexistent in medieval Islam as was the case among
other civilizations of the period. The medieval scientist was a person
who had encyclopedic interest in all the known sciences of the day and
Andalusian scientists belonged to the same intellectual species. In
contrast to the modern specialist who knows more about less, the
medieval scientist knew something about everything. Although these
medie\ral scientists might appear to be “generalists,” they created new
knowledge in the different sciences, thereby contributing to the
advancement of those disciplines in factual content, technical methods
and even in the creation of new independent scientific disciplines.
Algebra, trigonometry, optics and engineering were the most well known
of the new disciplines created by Muslim scientists.
It is important to note that medieval sciences were classified and
organized on the basis of epistemic principles different from the ones
used in modern science. For example, when scientists mentioned
mathematics, they were not referring to the domain of study we today
classify by the same name. Their idea of mathematics included the
subjects of astronomy and music in addition to arithmetic and geometry.
Only the most accomplished names in Andalusian science are mentioned
here. There were many other lesser known figures who contributed to the
field. All names mentioned were Muslims, but the scientific enterprise
in Andalusia was the result of collaborative efforts by Muslim, Jewish
and Christian scholars and scientists. Muslims led and dominated the
field of science and technology and were credited with most of
Andalusia’s scientific discoveries and innovations. The period of growth
and expansion in Andalusian science, however, also witnessed the
collaborative efforts of Muslim, Christian and Jewish scholars,
researchers and translators in the production of new knowledge and in
its cross-cultural diffusion. We may mention the role of Jewish and
Christian translators in advancing the ongoing Muslim synthesis,
philosophical and scientific, and in the dissemination of Islamic
science in their religious communities.
The nature and role of translation activities as a factor of
scientific growth needs to be noted. Scholars of the three faiths
participated in these activities for linguistic and scientific reasons,
and succeeded in translating Arabic works into Hebrew Latin and
Castilian, and revising existing Arabic translations of Greek works.
Translations were carried out either by individuals or “schools.”
Important from the point of view of intercultural relations in Andalusia
were the schools of translators. Worth mentioning is the 10th century
group of translators in Cordova associated with the Jewish physician,
Hasday ibn Shaprut, and the 13th century translation school in
Christian-ruled Toledo, patronized by Alfonso the Wise (Alfonso X el
Sabio) (1221-1284). Ibn Shaprut was instrumental in organizing the
Cordova community of Jewish scholars and supporting Hebrew translations
of Arabic works. Alfonso the Wise, on the other hand, was noted for his
great interest in the translations of Arabic works into Latin. Both the
Cordova and Toledo groups of translators included Muslims, Jews and
Christians, some of whom were trilingual or scientists in their own
right.
HIGHLIGHTS OF ACHIEVEMENTS IN AND ALUSIAN SCIENCE
Andalusia had excelled primarily in botany and agriculture, astronomy
and medicine. The leading botanists were Abu ‘Ubaid al-Bakri and Ibn
Hajjaj in the 10th century, al-Ghafiqi (d. 1 165) and Ibn al-Awwam in
the 1 1 th century, Abu’l-’Abbas al-Nabati and Abu Marwan Ibn Zuhr (d.
about 1 161) in the 1 2th century, and Ibn al-Baytar in the 13th
century. They are among the greatest medieval botanists for their
production of the period’s most excellent writings on botany and
agriculture. The Book of Agriculture (Kitab alfalahah) by Ibn alAwwam is
considered the most important medieval work on the subject. It
contained 34 chapters dealing with agriculture and animal husbandry.
More than 580 plants came up for treatment in the book not to mention
the discussion of 50 fruit trees for cultivation. The book was also
noted for its treatment of plant diseases and their remedies, and its
pioneering attempt to discover a new soil science.
Al-Ghafiqi was a renowned collector of plants in Spain and Africa. On
the basis of this collection, he wrote about drugs and plants, which
turned out to be the most accurate work in the history of Islam. In the
words of writer George Sarton, AlGhafiqi was “the greatest expert of his
time on simples. His description of plants was the most precise ever
made in Islam; he gave the names of each in Arabic, Latin and Berber.”
Ibn al-Baytar was perhaps the greatest pharmacist of medieval times.
He was considered to have written the best work on the subject of simple
drugs, with his description of more than 1,400 medical drugs as an
outstanding encyclopedic work unsurpassed during the period. Al-Nabati
or Abu’l'Abbas the botanist was known for his writings on plants found
along the African coast from Spain to Arabia.
It is quite clear that Andalusian botanists were interested in plants
for their theoretical considerations and practical applications. The
pursuit of botany was closely linked to the application of this
knowledge to agriculture and medicine. Not surprising!)’, Andalusia came
to be noted for its advanced agriculture, unique botanical gardens and
outstanding achieve ments in pharmacology. The Arabs introduced an
ingenious irrigation system in Andalusia, thus allowing its agriculture
to become the most advanced of the medieval period. Such elaborate
irrigation systems supplied water to fields and gardens and, along with
the advanced practice of agriculture and horticulture, Andalusia was
able to modify the Persian garden “into a new form, which has survived
to this day as the Spanish garden.”
Andalusia also excelled in medicine. It produced notable figures in
Islamic medicine, each of whom authored the most advanced medical
treatises of the time, thus helping to chart a new course for medical
theory and practice. Interestingly, Andalusia’s most famous philosophers
were also physicians. Among them were Ibn Tufail, Ibn Rushd and the
Jewish philosopher, Maimonides. Ibn Rushd, better known as a commentator
on Aristotle, was credited with several medical works including an
encyclopedia entitled The Book of Generalities on Medicine, and his
commentaries on Ibn Sina’s medical works. Maimonides wrote 10 medical
works, all in Arabic.
Andalusia’s fame in medicine was gained through the work of
al-Zahrawi, the greatest Muslim figure in surgery. Concession Kitab
al-tasrif), the work that earned him the title “father of surgery,” was
translated into Hebrew, Latin and Castilian. The treatise on surgery is
only one of 30 volumes of a medical encyclopedia treating all aspects of
medicine and contained much that was original. It has been widely
recognized in the Muslim world and the West as the “first independent
surgical treatise ever written in detail.” The work also included an
unprecedented 200 pictures of surgical instruments, many of which had
been invented by al-Zahrawi himself. Included in the treatise are
detailed descriptions of all known surgical operations and the
instruments used in each of them. Of all medical works produced by
Muslims, alZahrawi’s book was, until modern times, second only to Ibn
Sina’s Canon of Medicine in popularity among medical circles in the
West.
Abu Marwan Ibn Zuhr, the most famous member of the Avenzoar family (known for its two generations of distinguished medical doctors) is also worth mentioning. He wrote several medical works, the most important of which is the Book of Diets. Historians of medicine generally consider him the greatest clinical physician produced by Andalusia. Taking the medieval period as a whole, he is ranked second only to Muhammad ibn Zakariya al-Razi (d. 925), or Rhazes. In the field of pharmacology, which is closely related to botany and medicine, the works of al-Ghafiqi and al-Baytar were of general significance.
Abu Marwan Ibn Zuhr, the most famous member of the Avenzoar family (known for its two generations of distinguished medical doctors) is also worth mentioning. He wrote several medical works, the most important of which is the Book of Diets. Historians of medicine generally consider him the greatest clinical physician produced by Andalusia. Taking the medieval period as a whole, he is ranked second only to Muhammad ibn Zakariya al-Razi (d. 925), or Rhazes. In the field of pharmacology, which is closely related to botany and medicine, the works of al-Ghafiqi and al-Baytar were of general significance.
Related to medicine is the institution of hospitals and public
health. Andalusia was famous for its chain of hospitals, which was con-
sidered the most advanced in medieval times. It has been said that
Cordova alone had 50 hospitals and 900 public baths. As in other major
cities in medieval Islam, hospitals in Andalusia also played an
educational role not unlike that of our modern teaching hospitals.
As for Andalusian achievements in mathematics and astronomy, leading
astronomers were Abu’l-Qasim al-Majriti, who lived in the 10th and nth
centuries, al-Zarqali in the nth century and Jabir ibn Aflah in the 12th
century. Although alMajriti was an astronomer and alchemist, he was
more famous for his Hermetical and occult writings. Nonetheless, he was
an accomplished astronomer with several works on the subject to his
credit. His writings include several commentaries on the astronomical
tables of the famed mathematician from the East, Muhammad ibn Musa
al-Khwarazmi. He also commented on the Planisphaenum of Ptolemy and
wrote a treatise on the astrolabe.
But the person who should be regarded as the most outstanding
astronomer from Andalusia is al-Zarqali. He was an inventor who became
famous for the sahifah, a flat kind of astrolabe, which gained the
attention of Western astronomers after detailed descriptions of it were
published in Latin, Hebrew and several other European languages. As an
observational astronomer, his most important contribution is the editing
of the Toledan Zij (“The Toledo Tables”). This astronomical table,
based on observations carried out in Toledo, was really the product of
collaborative work al-Zarqali had carried out with several Muslim and
Jewish scientists. Like his sakifah, the Toledo Tables attracted wide
attention among astronomers in the Muslim and Latin worlds and were used
by them for centuries. Copernicus, in his famous book De Revolutionibus
Orbium Clestium (On the Revolutions of the Celestial Spheres),
acknowledged al-Zarqali’s contributions to astronomy. In the theoretical
domain, al-Zarqali wrote the explicit proof of the motion of the apogee
of the sun with respect to the fixed stars. He measured its rate of
motion as 12.04 seconds per year, which is remarkably close to the
modern calculation of 1 1 .8 seconds.
An important development in Andalusian astronomy in the 1 2th century was the growing criticism that had been directed against the Ptolemaic planetary system. The first to express dissatisfaction with the system was Jabir ibn Aflah, followed by strong criticisms from philosophers such as Ibn Bajjah and Ibn Tufail, who were motivated by the intellectual need to defend the Aristotelian cosmological scheme. These criticisms did result in one or two new theories. Ibn Bajjah proposed a system based on eccentric circles, whereas Ibn Tufail presented his theory of spiral motion, which presented the system as one of homocentric spheres. Although these new theories did not find any practical applications, the Andalusian critiques of Ptolemaic astronomy left an impact on the minds of Renaissance astronomers.
An important development in Andalusian astronomy in the 1 2th century was the growing criticism that had been directed against the Ptolemaic planetary system. The first to express dissatisfaction with the system was Jabir ibn Aflah, followed by strong criticisms from philosophers such as Ibn Bajjah and Ibn Tufail, who were motivated by the intellectual need to defend the Aristotelian cosmological scheme. These criticisms did result in one or two new theories. Ibn Bajjah proposed a system based on eccentric circles, whereas Ibn Tufail presented his theory of spiral motion, which presented the system as one of homocentric spheres. Although these new theories did not find any practical applications, the Andalusian critiques of Ptolemaic astronomy left an impact on the minds of Renaissance astronomers.
SIGNIFICANCE OF ANDALUSIAN SCIENCE
Andalusian science is significant for our times: it shows that
members of the three Abrahamic faiths can work together to produce a
common culture and civilization. It helped expand medieval science to
new frontiers and influenced the development of science in the West
during the Renaissance, which subsequently lead to the rise of modern
science. For the contemporary Muslim world, Andalusia shows the way
Islam can again be a source of inspiration for progress in science
within the context of a pluralistic world.
Bakar, O. (1996) 'Science', in S.H. Nasr and O. Leaman, History of Islamic Philosophy, London: Routledge, ch. 53, 926-46. (Discussion of some of the main thinkers and principles of science in Islam.)
ReplyDelete* Dani, A.H. (1973) Al-Biruni's India, Islamabad: University of Islamabad Press. (Al-Biruni's research on the people and country of India.)
Fakhry, M. (1983) A History of Islamic Philosophy, London: Longman, 2nd edn. (A general introduction to the role of reason in Islamic thought.)
Hill, D. (1993) Islamic Science and Engineering, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. (The classic work on the practical aspects of Islamic science.)
Hourani, G. (1975) Essays on Islamic Philosophy and Science, Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. (An important collection of articles on particular theoretical issues in the philosophy of science.)
Hourani, G. (1985) Reason and Tradition in Islamic Ethics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (A discussion of the clash between reason and tradition in Islamic culture as a whole, especially in ethics.)
* Ibn Tufayl (before 1185) Hayy ibn Yaqzan (The Living Son of the Vigilant), trans. S. Oakley, The Improvement of Human Reason Exhibited in the Life of Hai Ebn Yokhdan, Zurich: Georg Olms Verlag, 1983. (This translation of Hayy ibn Yaqzan was first published in 1708.)
Kirmani, Z. (1992) 'An Outline of Islamic Framework for a Contemporary Science', Journal of Islamic Science 8 (2): 55-76. (An attempt at conceptualizing modern science from an Islamic point of view.)
Leaman, O. (1985) An Introduction to Medieval Islamic Philosophy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (A general approach to the role of philosophy in Islam.)
Nasr, S.H. (1993) The Need for a Sacred Science, Richmond: Curzon Press. (An argument for the significance of religion in any understanding of science.)
Pines, S. (1964) 'Ibn al-Haytham's Critique of Ptolemy', in Actes du Xe Congrès internationale d'histoire des sciences, Paris: Ithaca. (One of the most important works in Islamic astronomy.)
* Sabra, A.I. (1972) 'Ibn al-Haytham', in C.C. Gillispie (ed.) Dictionary of Scientific Biography, New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 6th edn. (An excellent introduction to the thought and work of Ibn al-Haytham.)
Said, H.M. (ed.) (1979) Al-Biruni Commemorative Volume: Proceedings of the International Congress held in Pakistan, November 26-December 12, 1973, Karachi: Hamdard Academy. (Contains numerous papers discussing all the major works of al-Biruni.)
Saliba, G. (1991) 'The Astronomical Tradition of Maragha: A Historical Survey and Prospects for Future Research', Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 1 (1): 67-100. (A study of a particularly well-developed period of astronomical research in the Islamic world.)
Sardar, Z. (1989) Explorations in Islamic Science, London: Mansell. (Some contemporary debates on the nature of Islamic science.)
Young, M.J.L., Latham, J.D. and Serjeant, R.B. (1990) Religion, Learning and Sciences in the Abbasid Period, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (The leading work on the most important period for science in the Islamic world.)
Artikel ini adalah hasil penulisan Osman Bakar yang membincangkan tentang zaman keemasan sains dan teknologi di Andalus. Setelah hampir tujuh abad pentadbiran Islam bertapak di bumi Andalus, Andalus telah mencapai pencapaian yang tinggi dalam sejarah, kebudayaan dan ketamadunan. Sumbangan Andalus dalam ketamadunan amat lah besar terutamanya dalam bidang matematik, pertanian dan perubatan. Penulis menjelaskan bahawa abad ke 11M dipilih sebagai zaman kegemilangan sains dan teknologi di Andalus.
ReplyDeleteRantau ini telah dikira sebagai pusat penyelidikan sains paling maju di Eropah. Dengan itu tidak hairanlah berlaku banyak pertukaran maklumat saintifik di antara Andalus dengan seluruh dunia Islam. Banyak penghijrahan yang telah dilakukan oleh umat islam ketika itu dalam mendapatkan maklumat saintifik dan mengembangkan ilmu ke seluruh dunia Islam lain. Penghijrahan tersebut dilihat salah satu factor penting dalam pengantarabangsaan dan globalisasi sains dan teknologi Islam.
Dalam artikel ini, penulis ada menyatakan bahawa perkembangan sains dan teknologi di Andalus adalah hasil gabunmgan usaha ulama dan saintis Islam, Yahudi dan Kristian. Islam mengetuai dan mnguasai bidang sains dan teknologi dan telah dikreditkan dengan banyak penemuan inovasi dan saintifik Andalusia.
Dalam bahagian kedua, penulis telah membincangkan tentang tokoh-tokoh yang lahir pada zaman itu dan menceritakan sedikit sumbangan tokoh tersebut dalam bidang yang tersendiri. Dalam bidang pertanian, penulis telah mempersembahkan Ibn Awwam, al-Ghafiqi dan Ibn al-Baytar. Manakala dalam bidang perubatan, penulis menerangkan tentang al-Zahrawi, Abu Marwan Ibn Zuhr dan al-Razi yang amat penting selain menghasilkan banyak perkembangan dalam bidang sains perubatan. Al-Majriti, al-Zarqali dan Jabir ibn Aflah pula dikaitkan dengan bidang matematik dan astronomi.
Pada akhir penulisan artikel ini, penulis telah membincangkan akan kepentingan sains Islam di Andalus. Bagi dunia Islam kontemporari, Andalus telah menunjukkan bahawa Islam boleh menjadi sumber inspirasi kepada kemajuan sains dan teknologi dalam konteks dunia yang majmuk.